All Reviews
Holly Miller
2 weeks agoNot worth the price, and reteach the cook on how to evenly distribute the toppings on the pizza. Its like my 5 year old did it, which is ok for homemade pizza, not overpriced pizza. Reminds me of dominoes pizza....
Eric Sargent
3 weeks agoPizza was very good, ice cream was outstanding, and they were very nice to us when they didn't have to be. If I'm in this area again I'll definitely be coming back !!!
Trilby Pierce
a month agoWe ordered a medium pep n cheese with half jalapeños and a ham and cheese sub, and shared both. The sub was good, the ham was delicious. The bun remained soft, the lettuce and tomatoes were fresh. That being said, if the bun were crisped up ever so slightly, it would have been perfect. The pizza crust is quite thin, but it held up well to the toppings. Slight hint of sweetness in the sauce. The cheese is apparently a blend, it has a hint of smokiness to it, which I appreciated and enjoyed. The cheese is firmer and has a more toothy feel, so there wasn't really a "cheese pull", and we were okay with that because a lot of that pull can cause you to lose the toppings off your slice. 😏 The new building is very nice, there is several stools at the counter and a few booths and a couple tables with chairs. Nice and roomy. Entire visible area was clean and tidy. The staff was very nice and helped us promptly, which was a great service touch since she was working alone at the time. They also serve ice cream, I've added pics for the ice cream flavors and current prices. Will definitely visit again, especially for a sub.
Lee Meyer
3 months agoFood and service was trouble. The staff and owner lied about my order. The owner refused to check cameras on how they made my food correctly. I wish I never tipped them or did any business with this place. The owner accused me of lying and the owner lied to cover up her staff mistake.
Emrie Wisecarver
4 months agoWe ordered over an hour ago and we have yet to get our pizza and they won’t answer the phone
Tammy Zink
4 months agoI got a delicious sub. I mean really. I got a big sub that I could only eat half and two fountain drinks plus tip and delivery for 13 dollars. Yay I'll never order from any where else.
dave johnson
7 months agoI got a pizza 11/2025. I used to buy pizza at the old location it was good. The pizza was not done that I got this time. They need to learn how to make a pizza crust. Im sorry for this review. I was surpised on the lack of a crust.
Alejandro Gonzales
8 months agoExcellent pizza, friendly staff and clean facilities. Everything from the smiling crew welcoming us in, to the time we stepped out is proof that everyone at Old Town Pizza takes pride in what they do! Will definitely be coming back next time I'm in town